Quaker Theology in Five Acts

November 18, 2026

Friends Gen­er­al Con­fer­ence, the asso­ci­a­tion of Lib­er­al Quak­ers in North Amer­i­ca, has dis­trib­uted a new (at least new to me) copy of the famous Quak­er Vocal Min­istry Flow­chart. One could do a doc­tor­al the­sis com­par­ing the edits in sub­se­quent ver­sions of this and the the­ol­o­gy they assume or omit. Here’s one ques­tion’s evolution:

  • 1991: Mes­sage input from within? 1
  • 2014 : Do you per­ceive this mes­sage as a gift from the Holy Spirit?2
  • 2015 : I feel led to minister? 3
  • 2019: Is this mes­sage from the Holy Spirt and not from intel­lect or ego? 4
  • 2026: Is this mes­sage from beyond your­self, beyond intel­lect or ego? 5

The whole idea of a flow­chart is very com­put­er pro­gram­mat­ic so it seems fit­ting that the ear­li­est ver­sion describes the impulse to min­is­ter as a “mes­sage input.” The British ver­sion is just about as no-nonsense, ask­ing if we “feel led to min­is­ter.” There’s appar­ent­ly a ver­sion from the very ubiq­ui­tous Quak­er pas­tor Stan Thorn­berg in the July/August 1997 issue of the now-defunct Quak­er Life mag­a­zine (any­one have a copy they could scan?). The 2014 and 2019 ver­sions ask us to con­sid­er whether an incom­ing mes­sage is “from the Holy Spir­it” but the new ver­sion only asks if it’s “from beyond” (to be fair, this is clos­er to the 1991 input version).

I’ve said before I think these charts are less-than-helpful in a mod­ern reli­gious soci­ety where min­istry is often sparse and cliched. I don’t think Quak­er min­istry needs to be this hard. I love the sto­ries of the old Quietist-era min­is­ters. One was said to just rise to his feel when prompt­ed by the Holy Spir­it, with absolute­ly no idea what he was going to say. For him ris­ing was an act of faith that God would spon­ta­neous­ly pro­vide him with the words to speak. I’m sure pas­sages like Matthew 10​:19 – 20 were an inspiration:

But when they deliv­er you up, take no thought how or what ye shall speak: for it shall be giv­en you in that same hour what ye shall speak. For it is not ye that speak, but the Spir­it of your Father which speaketh in you.

Here’s his updat­ed flowchart:6

blank

In many Quak­er cir­cles it’s not cool to go back to the Qui­etist min­is­ters or point to the Bible pas­sages that shaped our cul­ture or even appar­ent­ly to talk as if we might expect the Holy Spir­it to be involved in Friends’ min­istry. So inputs and mes­sages from beyond it is. In the com­ments, tell me how you think this ques­tion will be posed cir­ca 2032 when a new ver­sion would be ready to drop? The blog should still be here and com­ments have time­stamps so you’ll have brag­ging rights if you guess it correctly!

I think Wess should call this “early deadoption”

November 12, 2026

My friend Wess Daniels is very cor­rect when he calls him­self an ear­ly adopter of social media. I’ve learned over the years to wait a few beats before fol­low­ing him down into some new cool ser­vice, just because who has the time? But to his cred­it, I’m pret­ty sure he was the first cheer­leader for Slack I had heard and I and my work col­leagues live in it all day now.

Over time he’s become more skep­ti­cal of social media:

These com­pa­nies have fig­ured out how to make mon­ey off of every frac­tion of a sec­ond we use these plat­forms, mean­ing their busi­ness mod­el is not about help­ing us do what we came to the plat­form to do, their mod­el is to make sure we stay on as long as they can pos­si­bly keep us there and bring us back as often as pos­si­ble. Dis­trac­tion and pre­oc­cu­pa­tion is the name of the game.

I’ve cut back and dead­opt­ed plen­ty of social media. I’ve become ever more com­fort­able in my per­son­al blog. But I do miss the cama­raderie of the old days. Twit­ter RIP was quite a com­mu­ni­ty. I’m active on Bluesky but I’ll post things I know are inter­est­ing and hear nothing.

This mon­th’s issue of Friends Jour­nal is our annu­al fic­tion issues. The idea to do fic­tion orig­i­nat­ed quite lit­er­al­ly in a 2021 tweet from Annalee Flower Horne: “Psst can we have a Quak­er sci­ence fic­tion anthol­o­gy.” I can’t think of any social media plat­form that has the mix of ban­ter and friend­ship and per­son­al­i­ty of gold­en age Twit­ter. The plat­forms kept chas­ing after mon­ey and algos; these days they’re full of AI slop. I can cer­tain­ly under­stand the moti­va­tion to deadopt.

Writing inspired by… Quaker meeting for business?

November 12, 2026

Novem­ber is fic­tion month for Friends Jour­nal. This week I inter­viewed Beck Daniel Wren about his sto­ry “Star­lings.” It’s a great tale that real­ly chal­lenges read­er to pon­der what iden­ti­ties we allow oth­ers — and our­selves — to see. There’s a lot that is top­i­cal in the sto­ry­telling (immi­gra­tion, gov­ern­ment cor­rup­tion, scape­goat­ing, etc.) but it’s all in ser­vice to the sto­ry — a real tes­ta­ment to the writ­ing craft.

I asked Beck one of my go-to ques­tions for fic­tion and poet­ry: what makes a lit­er­ary work Quak­er? It’s often an unan­swer­able ques­tion. Yes, some sto­ries in our fic­tion issues take place in Quak­er meet­ing­hous­es and most of our authors are them­selves Friends (though that isn’t a require­ment). But it’d be ter­ri­bly reduc­tive to make those require­ments for publication. 

Beck cred­its his immer­sion in Quak­er faith with a refine­ment of writ­ing style, point­ing to metaphors of light that infuse “Star­lings” and oth­er works. But even more sur­pris­ing­ly, he says the process of our busi­ness meet­ings has allowed him to trust the read­er and not over explain metaphors. “I can open doors, I can ask ques­tions, and I don’t have to pro­vide all the answers.” I love it! It’s a great inter­view all around. You can watch the whole inter­view or read the show notes and tran­scripts over at the FJ website.

Cropwell Meeting Open House

October 20, 2026

On Sun­day my meet­ing host­ed an open house to rein­tro­duce our­selves to our neigh­bors. Although the meet­ing has grown from five years ago — when only two peo­ple reg­u­lar­ly showed up at wor­ship — like all social bod­ies, we con­tin­ue to have ups and downs. A few ill­ness­es have recent­ly drawn some beloved reg­u­lars away. I’m con­vinced that regrow­ing a meet­ing is a 10-year project, at least, so we con­tin­ue on. The wor­ship is still deep and com­fort­ing. And the open house had a lot of great moments.

Living the 200-Year Present: An Interview with S​.​E​.​W. Smith

October 20, 2026

My Quak­er Talk inter­view with S​.​E​.​W. Smith, in which we talk about liv­ing with the eter­nal now and 200-year present. His arti­cle, Restore the Time, appears in the Octo­ber issue of Friends Jour­nal.

I’m a bit of a suck­er for what-if sce­nar­ios. A decade ago I got into Philip K. Dick­’s The Man in the High Cas­tle, which starts with the premise that the 1933 assas­si­na­tion attempt against FDR was suc­cess­ful and led step by step to the allies los­ing World War 2 (the 2015 TV series was also very well done). A cou­ple of years ago I addressed the debate going on about George Fox evad­ing a stronger stance against slav­ery while in Bar­ba­dos and won­dered if such a move would have destroyed the Quak­er move­ment: what might have hap­pened in such a scenario?

Show notes and tran­script.

How Do We Talk About Quaker Worship? Balancing Belief and Practice

October 14, 2026

I talked with Jack Tripp, who teach­es ninth and eleventh grade Eng­lish at the same Quak­er school he him­self attend­ed a decade or so ago. With a reli­gious tra­di­tion as fierce­ly anti-creedal as ours — and one that has mor­phed and evolved into var­i­ous con­tra­dic­to­ry forms — how do we describe our­selves? The prob­lem is height­ened in a Quak­er school set­tings, where only a frac­tion of stu­dents will be Quak­er them­selves. Jack­’s arti­cle, Toward a Quak­er Pedi­gree, is in the online edi­tion of this mon­th’s Friends Jour­nal.

Show notes and transcript

Also, I don’t think I ever shared last mon­th’s Quak­er Talk pod­cast inter­view with Michelle Downey, “How a Quak­er Meet­ing Wel­comes Mil­i­tary Fam­i­lies.” I also wrote the intro­duc­tion to the Octo­ber issue, “Restor­ing Our Parts of the World.”

Turning Weapons into Peace: My Interview with Scotty Utz

September 14, 2026

I inter­viewed Sep­tem­ber FJ author Scot­ty Utz about Guns-to-Garden Move­ment. Fas­ci­nat­ing wit­ness and some heart­break­ing sto­ries. From my intro:

One of the most pro­found and oft quot­ed state­ments from prob­a­bly the entire Bible is from Isa­iah, and it goes And he shall judge among the nations, and shall rebuke many peo­ple, and they shall beat their swords into plough shares, and their spears into prun­ing hooks. Nations shall not lift up sword against nation, nei­ther shall they learn war any more. And this may seem like a won­der­ful lyri­cal kind of state­ment. But what if we actu­al­ly took it seri­ous­ly and actu­al­ly start­ed tak­ing our instru­ments of war and turn­ing them into prun­ing hooks?

Full show notes and tran­scrip­tions here.

“Creationtide” and the Seasons of the Church and Earth

September 6, 2026

A beau­ti­ful med­i­ta­tion by Bri­an Dray­ton on Quak­ers soft­en­ing on the ideas of times and sea­sons and how he (and I sus­pect many oth­er Friends) have come to more ful­ly embrace the sea­sons of both the wider Chris­t­ian Church and also the nat­ur­al sea­sons of the earth and cosmos.