Friends General Conference, the association of Liberal Quakers in North America, has distributed a new (at least new to me) copy of the famous Quaker Vocal Ministry Flowchart. One could do a doctoral thesis comparing the edits in subsequent versions of this and the theology they assume or omit. Here’s one question’s evolution:
- 1991: Message input from within?
- 1987: Is the message from the Holy Spirit and not just from you?
- 2014 : Do you perceive this message as a gift from the Holy Spirit?
- 2015 : I feel led to minister?
- 2019: Is this message from the Holy Spirt and not from intellect or ego?
- 2026: Is this message from beyond yourself, beyond intellect or ego?
See my post about the flowcharts for details on each of these charts.





The whole idea of a flowchart is very computer programmatic so it seems fitting that the earliest version describes the impulse to minister as a “message input.” The British version is just about as no-nonsense, asking if we “feel led to minister.” The 1987, 2014 and 2019 versions ask us to consider whether an incoming message is “from the Holy Spirit” but the 2026 version only asks if it’s “from beyond” (to be fair, this is closer to the 1991 input version).
I’ve said before I think these charts are less-than-helpful in a modern religious society where ministry is often sparse and cliched. I don’t think Quaker ministry needs to be this hard.
But I do appreciate that there’s a discernment process in worship and I do look within myself to ponder my internal motivations for speaking. But the questions are different. Some are the same ever week, related to the struggles I go through in my spiritual life, while others are contextual and spontaneous. I think it was from Lloyd Lee Wilson that I got the concept of the Tempter — not a manifested devil with a pitchfork and red suit, but a cosmic force that works on our pride. If we think we have something figured out, the tempter will use that confidence to knock us back off course. For example, our satisfaction with moving toward the Light in some small matter might easily generate judgement that others around us haven’t made the same change. I know I often have to just laugh at myself and not take myself too seriously.
In worship, some of my discernment questions as a piece of ministry starts to arise might be:
Am I hoping to make myself look smart or extra-devout? Am I trying to argue some point in an ongoing debate in the meeting? Am I trying to convince a particular attender that might have annoyed me recently? Am I trying to fill the space because no one else has spoken? If a story has come to me should I say it all or simplify?
That’s not really the same flowchart. And it can’t be the same flowchart even for me week after week, because I grow and backslide in the Light constantly. I have shifts happen within me during the hour or so of worship itself. What I’m saying: I don’t think discernment can’t be separated from itself. Friends talk of integrity and one of the most important definitions is something which cannot be divided into smaller parts. The work of discernment is the work itself. There’s no shortcuts. A static chart can give us ideas but our relationship to the risen Christ is immediate and needs our attention right then, right there.
I love the stories of the old Quietist-era ministers. One was said to just rise to his feel when prompted by the Holy Spirit, with absolutely no idea what he was going to say. For him rising was an act of faith that God would spontaneously provide him with the words to speak. I’m sure passages like Matthew 10:19 – 20 were an inspiration:
But when they deliver you up, take no thought how or what ye shall speak: for it shall be given you in that same hour what ye shall speak. For it is not ye that speak, but the Spirit of your Father which speaketh in you.
Here’s his updated flowchart:1

In some Quaker circles it’s not cool to go back to the Quietist ministers or point to the Bible passages that shaped our culture or even apparently to talk as if we might expect the Holy Spirit to be involved in Friends’ ministry. The most recent flowcharts from FGC are adaptations of one published by Stan Thornburg in a 1998 article for Quaker Life magazine. When I asked if anyone had it, Johan Maurer scanned it in and sent it. I very much recommend reading the article (PDF). As far as I know there are no online archives of Quaker Life so let me quote the section on ministry:
This sense of being thus engaged is the “exercise” or the Holy Spirit. It is in this exercise that lives are transformed, Friends are called to acts of ministry, evil or self-destructive behavior is exposed and condemned, and the life of obedience and spiritual maturity moves a step toward Christ-likeness. This is the “work” of worship and the fruits of corporate attention to the voice of Jesus Christ.
Even those Friends who are most experienced in worship often question their leadings to speak out of the silence of open worship. The chart…. is meant to offer guidance in discerning whether to speak in open worship or remain silent. In the end, however, each worshiper is encouraged to obey the leadings of the Holy Spirit as he or she experiences it.
In the comments, tell me what you think this chart will look like in 2032 when a new version should be ready to drop? The blog should still be here and comments have timestamps so you’ll have bragging rights if you guess it correctly!